Sharp bounds and testability of a Roy model of STEM major choices
Authors: Ismael Mourifie, Marc Henry, and Romuald Meango
We analyze the empirical content of the Roy model, stripped down to its essential features, namely sector specific unobserved heterogeneity and self-selection on the basis of potential outcomes. We characterize sharp bounds on the joint distribution of potential outcomes and testable implications of the Roy self-selection model under an instrumental constraint on the joint distribution of potential outcomes we call stochastically monotone instrumental variable (SMIV). We show that testing the Roy model selection is equivalent to testing stochastic monotonicity of observed outcomes relative to the instrument, We apply our sharp bounds to the derivation of a measure of departure from Roy self-selection to identify values of observable characteristics that induce the most costly misallocation of talent and sector and are therefore prime targets for intervention. Special emphasis is put on the case of binary outcomes, which has received little attention in the literature to date. For richer sets of outcomes, we emphasize the distinction between pointwise sharp bounds and functional sharp bounds, and its importance, when constructing sharp bounds on functional features, such as inequality measures. We analyze a Roy model of college major choice in Canada and Germany within this framework, and we take a new look at the under-representation of women in STEM.
Please note that abstracts only appear in the language of the publication and might not have a translation.
M. Baker, J. Gruber, and K. Milligan (2008).
Universal childcare, maternal labour supply, and family well-being
Journal of Political Economy , 709-745
Brahim Boudarbat and Claude Montmarquette (2018).
L’inadéquation éducation-emploi et son impact sur les revenus chez les travailleurs canadiens / Mis-match between education and employment: The impact on the earnings of workers in Canada
Cahiers Québécois de démographie , 109-134
Pierre-Yves Cortès (2011).
Évolution des performances scolaires lors de la transition secondaire-Cégep: influences respectives des évaluations PISA, des performances scolaires antérieures et des contextes de vie
David L. Walters (2004).
The relationship between post-secondary education and skill: Comparing credentialism with human capital theory
Canadian Journal of Higher Education / Revue canadienne d'enseignement supérieur , 97-124
Stéphane Moulin, Pierre Doray, Benoît Laplante, and Maria Constanza Street (2013).
Work intensity and non-completion of university: Longitudinal approach and causal inference
Journal of Education and Work , 333-356
Christine M. Neill (2008).
The effect of student loan limits on university enrolments
CLSRN Working Papers